The track record for eachWatch Dogsstory has been pretty average overall, never overtly bad but never outstanding either. With each game there’s been a slide towards satire and easygoing hacktivism, withWatch Dogs 2never taking itself too seriously. That notion is further elevated inWatch Dogs Legion, taking the story all the way into a futuristic surveillance state full of London caricatures. The world and the characters ofLegionare all charismatic rebels taking on a comically villainous leader of a private militia.
This year’s iteration ofWatch Dogsfinds itself in a unique position for a lot of reasons, but especially from a storytelling perspective. Since there’s no static protagonist, and there are multiple playable protagonists, the story ofWatch Dogs Legionneeds to be especially adaptable to all characters and backgrounds. While the city of London depicted in the game is struggling under some extraordinary circumstances, it does mean the storytelling won’t treat every player equally.
RELATED:Watch Dogs Legion Trailer Introduces Villain Nigel Cass and More
Pro: Not Taking Itself Too Seriously
Frankly the best thing that happened toWatch Dogsin general was when the story never took itself too seriously. The first game set a precedent that it was meant to be a serious revenge story, with Aiden Pearce avenging his dead niece and rescuing his sister from a hitman from his past. Many criticized the firstWatch Dogs' plot because it did not match the gameplay loop in any way, both from Aiden’s perspective and the player’s perspective.Watch Dogs2remedied this by adopting a much more campy carefree story, bolstered byGrand Theft Auto-esque gameplay. NowWatch DogsLegionintends to do the same,with its wacky playable characters and charismatic story of rebellionagainst tyrannical martial law.
Watch Dogs Legion’s overarching storyline features relatively serious themes, but from a realistic perspective only seems plausible. In a way this is a genius approach to narrative, as it presents players with a rebellion born from the clever hacking group of DedSec. Every member of DedSec inLegionis a charismatic but vocal opposer of the tyrannical Albion militia that’s taken over London. These characters don’t seem unrealistic because in a lot of ways it’s a reflection of modern world politics and the people’s attitude towards them. Plus martial law and systematic oppression of citizens is a good reason to justifythe variety of violent gameplayWatch Dogs Legionis highlighting.
The Problem of Leveraging Gameplay with Story
Although with multiple playable protagonists inWatch Dogs Legion, this presents a problem. There’sno centralizing anchor point for players to keep themselves groundedor get attached to. Plenty of players have their favorite video game protagonists, but not having one static playable character is something video games really haven’t done on a mainstream level in a long time.Watch Dogs Legionis proposing that not only does that not matter, but that the narrative largely takes a backseat to gameplay anyway. Regardless of whether that’s true or not, the game is largely advertising the takedown of Albion being the primary objective of players inWatch Dogs Legion.
AssumingWatch Dogs Legionis gunning for theGrand Theft Auto-esque approach, it could be at a severe deficit to the story the game is trying to tell. Story-wise, given thatevery character is playable and has their own respective back story, that’s a lot of writing work to be done for several people. Even if each character in the game eventually leads to the same conflict with rebellion, it circumstantially lessens the impact of each character’s backstory, considering they all arrive at the same conclusion of hating Albion because tyranny is bad, etc. Every character beats to the same drum, likely at the cost of nuance and justification of each character’s actions.
RELATED:The Future of Ubisoft: Assassin’s Creed Valhalla, Far Cry 6, Watch Dogs Legion, and More
Con: Legion’s Story Could Take an Unfortunate Backseat
In the end, it may not matter if the gameplay is good enough, but this is somethingWatch Dogshas struggled with before. The aforementionedWatch Dogs 2’s plot featured a reckless and charismatic hacker Marcus Hollowayas the main character, but the gameplay didn’t fully reflect that. One of the biggest criticisms of Marcus as a protagonist was the ludonarrative dissonance between his personality and the potentially violent gameplay he could partake in. This may not exactly become a problem withWatch Dogs Legion, but the elimination of this dissonance means every character will have a streak of violence in their character. Even if players prefer to avoid confrontation and play stealthily/non-lethally, the game will need to leverage that with players who want to play guns blazing.
Therein lies a problem for both, as the game never leans too far into either side of those types of players. On the surface it seems likeWatch Dogs Legionis building this large and engrossing world full of unique characters. Upon closer inspection, these characters run the risk of seeming hollow because of their shared desires to takedown the oppressive militant forces occupying London. Theoretically every character will have a personal reason as to why they’ve joined the resistance, but the game will need to justify that feeling.Grand Theft Auto 5’s single-player has centralized charactersfor this exact reason. The game was confident enough to let its gameplay stand on its own, but tailored the personalities of its characters to match that level of violence players were capable of.
Watch Dogs Legion’s story will be interesting to see unfold because it runs into a problematic middle ground of story vs. gameplay.IfLegion’s gameplay truly is strong enough to stand independentlyfrom the narrative, then there won’t be a problem. But sinceWatch Dogsgames have consistently attempted to tell compelling stories of rebellion, the impact of said narrative may suffer as a result.
Watch Dogs Legionreleases on June 05, 2025 for PC, PS4, Stadia, and Xbox One. The game will also release on launch day for PS5 and Xbox Series X.
